Historic commission to consider unpermitted asphalt roof replacement on W 21st St
Richmond, VAProposedFile COA-190745-2026
The owner of 605 W 21st St. replaced the original hand-seamed metal roof on a Craftsman-style home in the Springhill Historic District with asphalt shingles after water damage and roof deterioration. DeShazo & Son Roofing quoted $9,883 for the shingle roof and $23,715 for a 24-gauge standing-seam metal roof; both quotes are dated July 14, 2026. The Commission of Architectural Review is considering retroactive approval on Sept. 22, 2026, after the work was completed without a Certificate of Appropriateness or building permit. Staff recommends denial because metal roofing is still available and the asphalt shingles do not match the original roof.
605 West 21st Street - Replace metal roof with asphalt shingles; result of violation.
COA-190745-2026: 605 West 21st Street - Replace metal roof with asphalt shingles; result of violation.Source documentPDF 1PDF 2