RLH OA 26-3: Appeal of Anne Thomas to a Denial of a Fence Variance at 737 WATSON AVENUE.

Description

Appeal of Anne Thomas to a Denial of a Fence Variance at 737 WATSON AVENUE.

Summary

Annie Thomas is appealing Saint Paul Building Official Nathan Bruhn’s August 27, 2026 denial of fence variance permit DSIBLDFH-052772-2026 for 737 Watson Avenue. The applicant seeks to replace a deteriorating enclosure on a corner lot with about 102 feet of six-foot cedar privacy fencing, steel posts, and a lockable gate. She cites existing fence damage, extensive street exposure, and preparation for a future Diabetes Assist Dog. Saint Paul rules limit fence heights, particularly near corner visibility areas. The appeal does not seek to waive safety standards: Thomas proposes a setback, lower height, open design, taper, or similar treatment where required to preserve sightlines and sidewalk access. She also asks the City to consider ADA reasonable-modification obligations and provide the written reasons supporting the denial. The matter may proceed to a Legislative Hearing Officer, who will review the evidence and recommend action to the City Council.